8 Best Eyeliners for the Perfect Wing: Expert Picks for Every Eye Shape

You’ve probably tried every eyeliner on the planet, yet the quest for the perfect winged eyeliner remains as elusive as the fountain of youth. But fear not, your struggles are about to become a thing of the past.

As a seasoned beauty writer, I’ve consulted with makeup experts to bring you a curated list of the top eight eyeliners that promise to deliver that flawless flick for any eye shape. Whether you’re blessed with almond eyes or you’re navigating the curves of a rounder gaze, there’s a liner here that’s tailored just for you.

But just when you think it’s all about the product, remember that technique plays a pivotal role, too. Stick around as we not only reveal our top picks but also share insider tips on how to achieve the perfect wing that will leave others in awe.

Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner, 36Hr Wear, Glossy Finish (Black)

For those seeking a dramatic and lasting winged eyeliner look, the Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner is your go-to product with its waterproof and 36-hour wear formula. It’s not only smudge-proof but also boasts a super-concentrated, oil-free formula that delivers intense color. The high pigmentation ensures you get that captivating glossy black finish every time.

Plus, it’s a breeze to apply thanks to the expert liner brush that glides smoothly over your skin, making it especially helpful if you’re just starting out with makeup. With this eyeliner, achieving a flawless wing or even experimenting with a smoky eye becomes effortless. It’s the perfect tool for making your eyes stand out, whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned pro.

Best For: Makeup enthusiasts and beginners looking for an intense, long-lasting, and easy-to-apply gel eyeliner.


  • The included expert liner brush allows for precise application.
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof formula ensures up to 36 hours of wear.
  • Highly pigmented for a glossy, intense black finish.


  • May require multiple swipes for achieving the desired level of intensity.

Blue Heaven Intense Eyeliner Easy Sketch, Black, 1ml Matte Finish

If you’re aiming for a flawless winged look, Blue Heaven Intense Eyeliner Easy Sketch with its precise felt tip and matte finish is your go-to choice. Originating from India, this eyeliner offers intense black color that dries quickly and won’t smudge or fade, ensuring your wings stay sharp all day. It’s waterproof and boasts a long-lasting formula. The pencil-like tip allows you to glide the product smoothly across your lash line, whether you’re crafting thin lines or bolder wings.

Although it’s budget-friendly, some users have noted it might take practice to achieve perfection. The tip can dry out, making it tricky to maintain a consistent flow, but when it works, it’s said to deliver an intense black with just one stroke. Remember, you’ll need a good makeup remover to take it off at the end of the day.

Best For: Individuals seeking a budget-friendly, long-lasting, and waterproof eyeliner with a precise felt tip for creating sharp winged looks.


  • Intense black color that provides a matte finish.
  • Quick-drying, smudge-proof, and fade-proof for all-day wear.
  • Waterproof and features a precise felt tip for detailed application.


  • May require practice to apply smoothly due to potential issues with the tip drying out.

SUGAR POP Waterproof Eyeliner with Felt Tip Applicator, Long Lasting & Intense Black

Achieving the iconic winged eyeliner look becomes effortless with the SUGAR POP Waterproof Eyeliner. Thanks to its precision felt tip and intense black pigment, you’ll love its lightweight, quick-drying formula that’s designed to last up to 12 hours. Whether you’re going for a bold graphic flick or a classic wing, the matte finish and hassle-free application make it a go-to for a slick look that lasts all day.

While it’s sweatproof, keep in mind that it’s water-resistant rather than fully waterproof. This means it might smudge under certain conditions, as some users have noted. However, the product’s quality shines with its 100% vegan and cruelty-free makeup, free from parabens. Despite mixed reviews, the positive feedback highlights its deep black color and ease of use.

Best For: Individuals seeking a vegan, cruelty-free eyeliner with a precision felt tip for creating bold and precise eye looks.


  • Intense black pigment for striking eye makeup
  • Long-lasting formula with up to 12 hours of wear
  • Easy to use with a precision felt tip applicator for various styles


  • Not completely waterproof as some users report smudging

Mamaearth Waterproof Glossy Finish Eyeliner with Almond & Castor Oil (3.5ml, Black)

Seeking a long-lasting, waterproof eyeliner that effortlessly glides to create the perfect wing? The Mamaearth Waterproof Glossy Finish Eyeliner, enriched with nourishing almond and castor oil, ensures a 10-hour hold for your bold eye statements. Hailing from India, this fade-proof and smudge-resistant marvel has climbed the ranks to #14 in eyeliners, with its sleek design measuring just 10 x 10 x 100 millimeters and a light weight of 20 grams. Users rave about its ease of use and durability, even up to the next morning, while those with sensitive skin hail it as a must-have. However, they do note that the scent isn’t great, and it can be tough to remove. With this eyeliner, you’re all set for a look that lasts.

Best For: Individuals seeking a long-lasting, waterproof eyeliner that’s suitable for sensitive skin and provides a glossy finish with the nourishing benefits of almond and castor oil.


  • Long-lasting wear up to 10 hours, with waterproof and smudge-resistant properties.
  • Compact and lightweight design, ranking #14 in eyeliners and appreciated for its ease of use.
  • Specifically formulated for sensitive skin, minimizing irritation and itchiness.


  • Difficult to remove, requiring multiple washes which may not be convenient for all users.

Maybelline New York The Colossal Bold Eyeliner, Black (The Archies Edition)

  • Not the best option for ultra-thin lines
  • Long-lasting and smudge-proof, but may need multiple layers for a darker look.
  • Despite minor shortcomings, it is still a standout choice in its price range.

Maybelline New York Hyper Glossy Liquid Eyeliner, Smudge Proof & Waterproof

If you’re after a high-shine finish that won’t budge all day, Maybelline New York Hyper Glossy Liquid Eyeliner is your go-to for crafting the perfect winged look. This highly pigmented eyeliner delivers a sleek, bold line that’s smudge-proof and waterproof, ensuring your wings stay sharp for up to 24 hours. The easy-to-use soft brush tip allows for a smooth application, creating a jet-black glossy shade that’ll make your eyes pop.

Users love how it holds up throughout the day without smudging, and its ease of use makes it a crowd favorite. You’ll find it’s one of the top liners for its price, offering a glossy finish that’s ideal if you’re not into matte looks. Plus, it dries up faster than competitors, so you won’t have to wait around. Just line, wing, and you’re ready to fly!

Best For: Individuals who want a glossy, smudge-proof and waterproof eyeliner that’s easy to apply and lasts all day.


  • Highly pigmented for a bold, jet-black glossy finish
  • Smudge-proof and waterproof formula ensures 24-hour wear
  • Quick-drying and easy to use with a soft brush tip for smooth application


  • May not be easily available in all stores

LAKMÉ Eyeconic Liquid Eye Liner, Black, Long Lasting & Waterproof (4.5 Ml)

Achieve the quintessential winged eyeliner with ease using LAKMÉ Eyeconic Liquid Eye Liner, designed for precision and longevity. Its unique flexi-tip brush allows for a precise application, perfect for crafting everything from an ultra-thin line to a dramatic cat eye. The intense black matte finish is assured with just one stroke, and you don’t have to worry about smudges or transfers; this liner’s formula is 24-hour smudge-proof and waterproof.

Customers rave about its smooth application and water-resistant properties, confirming that it’s suitable for daily wear. Despite some wishing for a better brush, the overall consensus is that it’s easy to use and worth the investment. It’s ophthalmologically tested, making it safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens users. Trust this LAKMÉ Eyeconic liner to last through hot lights and sweaty moments without a hitch.

Best For: Individuals seeking a long-lasting, waterproof eyeliner that’s suitable for sensitive eyes and a variety of dramatic and subtle looks.


  • Intense black matte finish that lasts 24 hours without smudging or transferring
  • Versatile application with a unique flexi-tip brush for various eyeliner styles
  • Ophthalmologically tested and safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers


  • The brush design could be improved for even easier application

FACESCANADA Magneteyes Eyeliner, Black (3.5ml, Matte Finish, Long Lasting)

Looking to create the ultimate winged eyeliner look? The FACESCANADA Magneteyes Eyeliner offers a matte finish that’s both waterproof and smudge-proof, ensuring your eyes make a bold statement all day. Infused with almond oil, this eyeliner isn’t just about aesthetics—it’s kind to your skin too.

Its quick-drying formula and fine tip allow for a sharp and precise application, which means you can achieve that perfect cat-eye with ease. Users rave about how it stays put for an impressive 24 hours without the need for touch-ups. It’s a breeze to use, gliding smoothly along your lash line, and when the day is done, it comes off without a fuss.

Despite a few negative reviews, it’s generally celebrated for its rich color and value for money. Remember, it’s vegan and cruelty-free, so you can feel good about the choice you’re making for your makeup kit.

Best For: Individuals seeking a long-lasting, smudge-proof eyeliner with a precise application and matte finish.


  • Enriched with almond oil, making it nourishing for the skin around the eyes.
  • Vegan and cruelty-free, appealing to ethically conscious consumers.
  • Features a fine tip for sharp, precise lines and detailed makeup looks.


  • Some users report that the product wears off easily and can have a faded appearance.

Factors to Consider When Choosing an Eyeliner

As you seek out your ideal eyeliner, it’s crucial to consider a range of factors that will affect your overall look. You’ll want to assess how the color complements your eyes, the longevity of wear, and whether the applicator gives you the control needed for that flawless wing.

Additionally, the consistency of the formula and the decision between waterproof and water-resistant options will play significant roles in your daily makeup routine.

Eyeliner Color Selection

Selecting the right eyeliner color can enhance your natural eye color and complement your skin tone, elevating your makeup look from simple to striking. A classic black eyeliner suits most eye colors and skin tones, offering a timeless appeal that’s perfect for any occasion. If you’re aiming for a softer, more natural vibe, especially for daytime events, brown eyeliner is your go-to.

Don’t be afraid to play with colored eyeliners to make your eyes pop—blue, green, or hazel eyes can truly shine with the right shade. Always consider the setting and the look you’re going for. A bold color might be perfect for a night out, while a more subdued tone could be ideal for a professional setting.

Wear Duration Claims

When choosing an eyeliner, it’s essential to check the product’s wear duration claims, such as 24-hour or waterproof, to ensure it can keep up with your day. Look for specific wear time claims like 36-hour or 12-hour wear. You’ll want to consider features like smudge-proof, waterproof, and sweat-proof properties for extended wear, especially if you’re active or live in a humid climate.

Don’t just take the packaging at face value—read customer reviews to get a feel for the eyeliner’s real-world performance. These insights can be invaluable.

Think about the activities you’ll be doing while wearing the eyeliner. Will you be sweating at the gym or caught in the rain? Make sure your eyeliner choice meets your longevity needs.

Applicator Type Precision

For the perfect winged look, consider the precision of the eyeliner’s applicator, as it plays a critical role in achieving sharp and defined lines. Precision applicator types are key for accurate, defined strokes, ensuring smooth application, especially for intricate styles like the winged effect. A fine tip or brush allows for exact, thin lines, catering to a range of looks from subtle to dramatic.

Different applicators offer versatility for either bold or delicate eyeliner effects. The right precision applicator can make a world of difference, providing a controlled, hassle-free experience. This is particularly useful if you’re a beginner in makeup. You’ll want an eyeliner that makes it easy to express your style with confidence and grace.

Formula Consistency

Understanding the consistency of your eyeliner’s formula—be it gel, liquid, or felt tip—is crucial for achieving a flawless application and the look you desire.

A quick-drying formula can be great for swift application, but it may require a steady hand. On the other hand, a creamy consistency offers more play time for blending but might smudge easier.

If you’re always on the go or have oily skin, you’ll want a formula that’s smudge-proof, waterproof, or sweat-proof. Check reviews for notes on pigmentation and longevity to ensure it lasts all day.

If you have sensitive eyes, look for eyeliners with natural oils or free from irritants.

Waterproof Vs. Water-Resistant

Choosing between waterproof and water-resistant eyeliners hinges on your daily activities and environmental exposure. If you’re a swimmer or live in a rainy climate, waterproof eyeliners are your go-to for enduring wear. They’re designed to not budge, ensuring your wing remains sharp and smudge-free, no matter the splash. On the other hand, water-resistant eyeliners can handle a bit of sweat and tears, but mightn’t stand up to a full dive into the pool.

Waterproof eyeliners last longer but require a tough makeup remover at the end of the day. If you’re after convenience for gentle removal, water-resistant might be your match. Consider your lifestyle and the occasions you’ll be donning your winged look to make the best choice.

Ingredient Safety Profile

When selecting an eyeliner, it’s crucial to scrutinize the ingredient list for potential irritants and harmful substances to ensure the safety of your delicate eye area. Keep an eye out for common allergens like fragrance, parabens, and formaldehyde-releasing preservatives, which can cause irritation or allergic reactions. You’ll want to steer clear of harsh chemicals such as phthalates, lead, and heavy metals—ingredients notorious for their negative health impacts.

Opt for eyeliners labeled hypoallergenic, non-comedogenic, and dermatologist-tested, especially if you’ve got sensitive skin. These products are typically gentler and less likely to cause issues. Also, consider formulas enriched with natural, nourishing ingredients like plant oils and extracts to promote the health of your eye area.

Lastly, check the brand’s cruelty-free and vegan status to match your ethical and environmental values.

Product Removal Ease

Before committing to an eyeliner, consider how easily you can remove it at the end of the day. Some formulas might necessitate special makeup removers or extra effort to avoid any lingering traces. Waterproof and smudge-proof options, while great for longevity, may be stubborn to take off. You’ll want to evaluate if you need a dedicated makeup remover to effectively cleanse your skin.

Assess the formulation and ingredients as these can impact not only removal ease but also how your skin reacts to the remover. Check user feedback on the product’s removal ease. Their experiences offer valuable insights into whether you’ll be scrubbing away at your eyes or if the liner will glide off with minimal fuss.

Price and Affordability

Assess your budget carefully as the price range of eyeliners varies widely across different brands and types. You’ll find options from budget-friendly drugstore finds to luxury high-end lines. When comparing affordability, don’t just look at the price tag; consider the product’s quality and how well it performs. Is it long-lasting, or will you find yourself reapplying throughout the day, leading to more frequent purchases?

Be mindful of hidden costs like shipping or taxes, which can add up. And keep your eyes peeled for promotions, discounts, or special offers that could sweeten the deal. Ultimately, you want an eyeliner that offers a balance between cost and effectiveness, ensuring you don’t sacrifice that perfect wing for the sake of your wallet.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Eyeliners Cause Allergic Reactions, and How Can I Test for an Allergy Before Applying the Product to My Eyes?

Yes, you can develop allergic reactions to eyeliners. To test for an allergy, apply a small amount on your inner arm and wait 24 hours to see if there’s any skin reaction.

Are These Eyeliners Suitable for People Who Wear Contact Lenses or Have Sensitive Eyes?

Yes, these eyeliners are suitable for contact lens wearers and those with sensitive eyes, as they’re specially formulated to be gentle and minimize irritation. Always check the label to confirm hypoallergenic properties.

How Can I Properly Remove Waterproof Eyeliners Without Irritating My Skin or Losing Eyelashes?

To remove waterproof eyeliner without irritating your skin, gently apply an oil-based makeup remover. Use a cotton pad, and don’t rub; just press and hold, then wipe away softly to protect your lashes.

What Are the Environmental Impacts of These Eyeliners, and Are Any Options Considered Eco-Friendly or Sustainable?

Many eyeliners contain harmful chemicals impacting the environment. Look for brands with sustainable practices and eco-friendly materials to minimize your ecological footprint while still achieving that flawless winged look.

Are There Any Eyeliner Application Tips for Individuals With Shaky Hands or Beginners Struggling to Achieve the Perfect Wing?

If you’ve got shaky hands or are new to eyeliner, start with short strokes instead of one long line. Rest your elbow on a surface and use tape as a guide for precision.


You’ve seen the top picks for acing that perfect winged eyeliner look, tailored for every eye shape.

Whether you’re after a glossy finish with Maybelline’s Lasting Drama or a smudge-proof option with LAKMÉ Eyeconic, there’s something for everyone.

Remember to consider staying power, ease of application, and the finish you love when making your choice.

Go on, define those eyes with confidence and let your perfect wings soar!

Related Articles

Back to top button